Tips for Handling Background Check Errors (for Job Seekers)

Published On: October 27th, 2025Last Updated: December 17th, 2025Categories: Job Seekers Blog, Tips & Advice
Tips for Handling Background Check Errors - Job Seekers Blog - JobStars USA

The following post explores Tips for Handling Background Check Errors.

Background checks are a routine part of the hiring process, but for some job seekers, they become a major obstacle. Errors such as false criminal records, outdated employment history, or mismatched identity information can delay job offers or even lead to rescinded employment.

Read: How Your Credit Score Impacts Your Job Search

Related: Reasons for Contacting an Employment Lawyer (as a Job Seeker)

Explore: CallMeChat

Companies like Checkr, a widely used background check provider, have been at the center of many such cases. For many individuals, encountering errors in a background check has led them to research their rights under federal law and ultimately consider a Checkr lawsuit as a means of protecting their name and career.

Here’s what you need to know.

How Background Check Errors Happen on Checkr

Automated background checks may streamline hiring, but they are prone to mistakes. Companies like Checkr rely on automated databases and matching algorithms to compile information about applicants.

These systems often match individuals based on names, birthdates, or general identifying data without verifying that the information belongs to the candidate. The result is that many people have records attached to them that actually belong to someone else. Outdated court data, expunged criminal records, and even simple clerical errors can lead to major consequences when an employer receives inaccurate information.

When these reports are submitted to a prospective employer, the consequences may include delayed hiring, rescinded offers, or even termination from a job that has already started. These issues are made worse by the fact that background check providers don’t always respond thoroughly to reported errors. To reduce such risks, many employers are now pairing background checks with AI recruitment software that adds additional verification layers and decision context before final hiring actions are taken.

The Emotional Toll of a False Checkr Report

An incorrect background check can take a serious emotional toll. Losing a job or opportunity due to an error in a background report can lead to feelings of embarrassment, stress, anxiety, and helplessness. The impact is particularly devastating when there is no wrongdoing on the part of the applicant. 

Efforts to resolve these mistakes can also be frustrating. Some individuals report difficulty reaching a real person at the background check company, or experience long delays when attempting to correct an error. These delays can stretch on for weeks – long enough for the job opportunity to disappear.

Disputing a False Checkr Report Yourself

The Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) gives consumers the right to dispute incorrect information found on background checks.

Providers like Checkr are required by law to investigate disputes and make corrections within 30 days. While this process exists, it is not always effective in a timely fashion. Submitting documentation, waiting for a re-investigation, and hoping for a correction may not be enough to save a job opportunity in question.

Individuals can file a dispute on their own, but many find that hiring an attorney ensures the issue is addressed more quickly and thoroughly. When income and employment are at stake, working with a legal professional to file a lawsuit may be the most effective option.

Paying the Price When Checkr Gets it Wrong

Background check providers process millions of reports each year. Even a low error rate means thousands of people may be affected. The most common background check mistakes include:

  • Criminal records belonging to another person
  • Expunged or sealed records still appearing
  • Inaccurate or outdated employment history
  • Incorrect status of pending charges
  • Mismatched or outdated identity and address data

Any one of these errors can damage someone’s job prospects and life. 

What the Law Says About Your Rights

Under the FCRA, background check companies must meet certain legal obligations. They are required to:

  • Provide you with a copy of your background report
  • Allow you the opportunity to dispute inaccuracies
  • Conduct a re-investigation within 30 days
  • Correct or remove unverifiable or inaccurate information

If a company fails to meet these obligations and you suffer harm as a result, you may have grounds to pursue compensation through a lawsuit. Legal remedies can include lost wages, emotional distress, and even punitive damages if the company acted willfully or negligently.

How a Lawsuit Can Make a Difference

Legal action can serve multiple purposes. It can help correct the false information, recover damages for lost job opportunities, and apply pressure on background check companies to improve their processes. Filing a lawsuit can compel the company to remove false or damaging information from your background report.

In some cases, it can also result in financial compensation for income lost due to job delays or rejections, as well as for the emotional harm suffered.

Many people hesitate to pursue legal action because it’s too costly or time-consuming. However, many attorneys who handle these cases work on a contingency fee basis (no upfront cost). A successful claim provides individual justice and encourages accountability within the background check industry.

Breaking Checkr’s Grip on Your Future

Experiencing job loss or delay because of an inaccurate background check can be frustrating and disheartening. However, consumers are not powerless. There are legal protections in place and proven paths to correct the damage.

Challenging false reports holds negligent reporting agencies accountable and prevents others from being harmed by the same flawed systems. Fighting back is not just about defending yourself – it’s about helping to ensure accuracy and fairness in hiring practices.

Benefits of Pursuing Legal Action

Clearing your name is essential, especially when incorrect criminal or identity records continue to appear in future reports. A successful lawsuit can result in the removal of harmful data. In addition, if a job offer was rescinded or your employment was delayed, you may be entitled to compensation.

Filing a lawsuit does not necessarily require financial resources. Many attorneys accept these cases without charging upfront fees. And perhaps most importantly, holding background check providers accountable creates pressure to correct and improve their systems, reducing the chance of errors affecting others.

No one should lose out on a job opportunity because of someone else’s mistake. The law is on your side, and the tools are available to fight back.

Choosing a Consumer Rights Lawyer

Navigating the FCRA dispute process alone can be overwhelming. A consumer rights attorney ensures deadlines are met, evidence is gathered, and your claim is presented effectively.

I recommend contacting Consumer Attorneys PLLC, they understand how background check errors impact your livelihood — and they fight to make it right.

In Conclusion

In conclusion, I hope this offers helpful tips for handling background check errors. Background checks are meant to protect workplaces, but when companies like Checkr provide inaccurate information, the consequences can be severe for job seekers. Mistakes in these reports can cost jobs and create lasting setbacks.

About the Author: Doug Levin

Doug Levin is the owner and operator of JobStars USA, a B2C career services practice serving job seekers of all industries and experience levels. He is a Certified Professional Resume Writer (CPRW) and Career Coach (CPCC) with more than a decade of experience in career services.

Share This Story, Choose Your Platform!